Resubmissions and ParentheticalsPosted by John Woodington on May 27th, 2010
I think I won’t write about not watching TV anymore. It is boring stuff, and I can only say so many times, “Hey, I’m still not watching TV.” It’s starting to sound like bragging, which means that’s the end of it. I’m not watching TV, and I’m not writing about not watching TV. The first rule of not watching TV is you don’t talk about not watching TV. Ditto on the second rule.
I think I’ve completed my best short story yet. It’s called “Memorial.” I’ve had free time to work on it in the evenings, and I finally got a printer up and running in our house, so I printed it off, edited it through a couple times, made two moderately major changes (set it in the present instead of the future, and removed clipped coloquial verbiage, both upon recommendations of trusted readers) and now I think it’s quite publishable. The problem? I’ve already submitted it to 17 places in its “set-in-the-future-with-clipped-coloquial-verbiage” form. So that sucks, because those 17 place were some of my top-tier places that I submit to, and since 13 of them have already rejected it, I can’t submit it to them again. So now it’s off to other markets, hopefully ones that pay more than just contributors copies.
I know many authors think that if a story (or poem or essay or poemessay(?)) is rejected, they can significantly revise that story and resubmit it as a new piece of material to the very place that has already rejected them. I don’t believe in that approach. I say if you get rejected, you keep a stiff upper lip and move on to the next venue, whether you revise the story or not. Were I an editor of a literary journal (or publishing house) I wouldn’t want to see the same story three times in three different draft forms. That’d be a waste of time. I’d say if an editor asks for a revision specifically, then go for it, but otherwise, don’t resubmit it even after significant editing.
(Also, I love parentheticals (and double-parentheticals) because they are so easy to drop in wherever you’d like.)